# The Roof Problem Homeowners Rarely See: Exposed Nail Heads and Flashing

> Unsealed nail heads on flashing are the most common problem we find on roofs. Why they leak, where they hide, and what a proper fix looks like.

Canonical page: https://www.rebornroofing.com/blog/exposed-nail-heads-and-flashing/

Reborn Roofing (Reborn Roofing, LLC) is a family-owned roofing company at 761 Chaney Drive, Collierville, TN 38017, serving Collierville, Germantown, Memphis and the surrounding Mid-South. Owners: Ken Cope and Brett Kittleson. Tennessee Home Improvement License #12119. GAF Certified contractor. BBB A+ accredited since 2023. 2024 Memphis Most Winner, Roofing Company. Google rating 5.0 from 119 reviews (2026-11-16). Phone (901) 300-3939. Hours: Monday to Friday 8am to 5pm, Saturday by appointment.

By Ken Cope, Owner and Partner. Published 2026-09-16.

**Why do exposed nail heads on roof flashing cause leaks?** Flashing is the metal that seals the joints around pipes, vents, chimneys and walls, and it is fastened with nails. Those nail heads are meant to be sealed. When they are left bare, or the sealant dries out and cracks, each one becomes a small opening that lets water reach the decking, often for months before a stain appears.

## The Most Common Thing We Find

Of everything we see on roofs around Collierville, Germantown and Memphis, unsealed nail heads on flashing are the single most common issue. On the majority of roofs we inspect, at least some of them are bare.

This is not only an old-roof problem. On roofs under about 15 years old, it is the leading source of the slow leaks we trace. In many cases the nail heads were never sealed in the first place. That is an installation shortcut, not wear, and it has been there since the day the roof went on.

A single nail hole sounds trivial. A roof has hundreds of fastener points, though, and the ones on flashing sit exactly where water is already being directed: around pipes, along walls and down valleys.

## Where Flashing Lives on Your Roof

Flashing is any piece of metal or formed material that seals a joint where the shingles alone cannot.

- Pipe boots: The collars around plumbing vent pipes. Most have a rubber gasket that dries out and splits with age; in our experience that often happens within eight to ten years.
- Chimneys: Step flashing along the sides and counter flashing set into the masonry. On wider chimneys, a small peaked cricket behind the chimney keeps water and debris from collecting there.
- Sidewalls and dormers: Step flashing woven into each course of shingles where a roof slope meets a vertical wall.
- Exhaust and attic vents: Each vent cap is fastened through its flange, and every one of those fasteners is a potential leak point.
- Valleys: Where two slopes meet and the heaviest water flow on the roof runs. Debris collects here too.
- Skylights and added equipment: Skylight flashing kits, satellite dish mounts and other items attached after the roof was installed.

## Why Nobody Notices Until It Is Expensive

You cannot see a nail head on a pipe boot from the yard. Even if you could, a few drops at a time do not announce themselves. The water soaks into the decking, wicks along the wood, and is absorbed by insulation before any of it reaches the drywall.

By the time a stain shows on a ceiling, the decking around that nail may be soft, the insulation below it wet, and the attic in that spot damp enough to grow mold. The repair is no longer a dab of sealant. It is new decking, new underlayment and new shingles over the affected area, plus whatever the interior needs.

## What These Problems Look Like Up Close

- F1 Bare nail heads on flashing. Observed: Shiny or rusted nail heads on a boot flange, vent cap or step flashing with no sealant over them. Usually means: An open path for water at every one. Sealing them is quick work when caught early.
- F2 Cracked sealant. Observed: Sealant that was applied once but has dried, shrunk and split after years of sun. Usually means: It looks protected from a distance but is not. It needs to be cleaned off and redone.
- F3 Split pipe boot gasket. Observed: The rubber collar around a vent pipe is cracked or pulling away from the pipe. Usually means: Water runs straight down the pipe into the attic. The boot gets replaced, not just sealed.
- F4 Lifted step flashing. Observed: Flashing along a wall or chimney that has pulled away, or was tucked behind the siding incorrectly. Usually means: Wind-driven rain gets behind it. It needs to be re-set or replaced, not caulked over.
- F5 Nail pops. Observed: Shingle nails that have backed out of the decking, lifting the shingle above them or coming through it. Usually means: A sign of an active leak path, and often a clue that the attic is not ventilating well.

## Work Done on Your Roof by Other Trades

NRCA points out that equipment added to a roof after installation, such as satellite dishes, solar panels and cable or internet connections, often is not flashed or connected to the roof correctly. It notes that this kind of work can damage a roof system or affect its warranty, and recommends asking a professional roofing contractor before adding equipment.

The same goes for any job that put people on your roof, including HVAC work. If someone has been up there recently, it is a good time to have the flashing checked.

## What a Proper Fix Looks Like

1. Find every one: We check each penetration, wall joint and valley, not just the area above a stain. If one nail head is bare, others usually are too.
2. Seal what can be sealed: Sound flashing with exposed fasteners gets cleaned and sealed with roofing sealant.
3. Replace what cannot: Cracked boots and failed flashing come out. We dry and inspect what is underneath, then install new flashing and seal it properly.
4. Show you the work: You get photos of what we found and what we did, so the record is yours.

## Sealant Is Maintenance, Not a Forever Fix

Roofing sealant lives in full sun on a dark surface. It holds up for years, but it does age, and NRCA lists replacing missing or damaged caulk among the basic tasks of preventive roof maintenance. That is why sealing flashing is part of every tune-up we do and part of our maintenance plans, rather than a one-time event.

If it has been several years since anyone looked closely at the flashing on your roof, that is reason enough to have it checked. It is one of the least expensive problems to fix on a roof, and one of the most expensive to ignore.


## Sources

- NRCA via Professional Roofing: Asphalt Shingle Roof Systems, A Homeowners Guide for Inspection, Maintenance and Repair (Nov 2020): https://www.professionalroofing.net/Articles/A-new-resource-for-consumers--11-01-2020/4787

## Contact

- Reborn Roofing, 761 Chaney Drive, Collierville, TN 38017
- Phone: (901) 300-3939
- Free roof assessment: https://www.rebornroofing.com/contact/
