Why Two Quotes for the Same Roof Can Be Far Apart
Most homeowners collect a few estimates, glance at the totals and start from the lowest. The trouble is that roofing quotes are rarely describing the same job. One may include new flashing everywhere; another may plan to reuse the old metal. One may price a full tear-off; another may lay new shingles over the old ones. One measured the roof; another estimated it from the size of the house.
NRCA puts it plainly in its guidance to storm-affected homeowners: price is only one criterion for choosing a roofing contractor, and a healthy skepticism about the lowest bid is warranted. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
What to Check on Every Quote
Lay the estimates side by side and look for each of these. If a quote is silent on one, ask.
How the roof was measured
Roofs are priced by the square, which is 100 square feet of roof surface. Ask whether the area came from a measurement report or a guess. Different totals sometimes start with different measurements.
Tear-off or overlay
A full tear-off down to the deck lets the decking be inspected and repaired. Laying new shingles over old ones skips that. We do full tear-offs on every replacement.
Decking
Nobody can see all the decking until the old roof is off. A good quote explains how damaged boards will be handled and priced, so there are no surprises mid-job.
Underlayment and leak barrier
What goes under the shingles, and where extra protection is used, such as valleys.
Flashing
New drip edge, step flashing, valley flashing and chimney flashing, or reused metal? Ask whether a chimney cricket has been evaluated.
Ventilation
Does the quote address intake and exhaust, including ridge ventilation, or just replace whatever vents are there?
Shingle line and accessories
The specific product, plus starter, ridge cap and pipe boots. Brand alone is not enough to compare.
Cleanup
Protection for plants, debris handling, and a magnetic sweep for nails at the end.
Did Anyone Get on the Roof?
A measurement report tells a contractor how big your roof is. It does not tell them whether the decking is soft around the chimney, whether the attic is venting, or whether there is a second layer of shingles underneath. Those details change the scope and the price.
A quote built after someone walked the roof and photographed it is more likely to hold up once the work starts. A quote built from the driveway is more likely to grow.
Questions That Separate Contractors
- 01
Will your own crew do the work, or a subcontractor?
TDCI suggests asking this of any contractor.
- 02
Who from your company will be on site?
At Reborn, a team member, usually our project manager George and otherwise Ken or Brett, is on site whenever work is being done.
- 03
What is your license, and can I look it up?
Tennessee licenses can be checked at verify.tn.gov. Ours is Tennessee Home Improvement License #12119.
- 04
What happens if you find rotten decking?
You want the answer before tear-off, not during it.
- 05
What workmanship coverage do you offer, in writing?
Contractor warranties vary widely from company to company, so compare the actual terms.
- 06
Can I talk to recent customers?
References and recent reviews you can verify are worth more than any sales pitch.
Ask How Changes Are Handled
Even a careful quote cannot see everything under the old shingles. What matters is how a contractor handles what they find. Ask whether changes are priced in writing and approved by you before the extra work is done, or simply added to the final invoice.
Also ask what is not included. Gutters, skylight replacement, interior repairs from an old leak and rotted fascia are all reasonable exclusions, as long as you know about them up front instead of discovering them on the bill.
If the Right Quote Is More Than You Planned
Financing is available on qualifying projects through Hearth's network of lending partners. Hearth is not a lender, all financing is subject to credit approval, and terms vary by lender. Checking your options does not affect your credit score, so you can see what is available before you decide.
And if replacement is not urgent, ask whether a repair can carry the roof for a season while you plan. Sometimes it can, and an honest contractor will tell you.





